Want to learn more about collecting old fishing lures? Patented February 25, 1908 by Jacob Hansen and Adolph Arntz of Muskegon, Michigan this lure features several sections in the tail end of the minnow to give it a moving, life-like swimming appearance as it was retrieved through the water. As you can see in the photo it is a beautiful example of the type of work that went on in Garrett, Indiana. Latest. Rarely seen for sale, this Moonlight Dreadnought is a beautiful example in the classic red and white finish, with brass washer hardware and twin unmarked spinners. Well you're in luck, because here they come. Most Valuable Heddon Frog $30,000 One of the rarest antique lures in existence today, hence the hefty price tag, this lure was hand-carved in 1897 by James Heddon of Dowa- giac, Mich. Heddon was one of the world’s larg- est producers of honey: He gave this lure to honey distributors as an incentive for them to buy his honey. In spite of the fading to this black example and some signs of wear, it sold for $125 (not including buyer's premium) at Morphy Auctions in November 2015. This bait is very rare circa 1915 and comes complete with its correct 2 piece Patent Pending picture box in near excellent condition and an unfaded clear paper illustration. Moonlight Dreadnought Antique Fishing Lures Image Source: mrlurebox.com. One of these "special" baits is this Creek Chub Plunker. Complete with a tail mechanism and fin design that clearly helps it stand out from others. Not as well known as some of the other brands featured here, Macatawa Bait Co. lures are also seen as collectible along with other less prolific companies. The first step in valuing these "mantiques" is to look for a brand such as Heddon, Pflueger, or Creek Chub Bait Co. (also referenced as CCB Co. by collectors and dealers) printed on the lure. If you are a collector of early Heddon lures and their boxes this is a rare and must have item. It was produced over several years in many different colorways. We have over 600 of them in stock There are 304 rare fishing lures for sale on Etsy, and they cost $48.92 on average. I always picture these somewhere out there undiscovered in some little old ladies house filled with spare buttons or safety pins and nobody knows what they have. This lure sold for $5,900 in 2015. Get DIY project ideas and easy-to-follow crafts to help you spruce up your space. The most common rare fishing lures material is cotton . It is extremely rare and in beautiful Natural Scale finish and probably is the nicest known example of the very few of its known kind. The earliest, prehistoric lures were made of bone. This one sold for over $13,000 at auction in 2007. Quick Facts. Fishing Lure with Box This is a nice vintage fishing lure in good condition with vintage box. Also marked on the bottom, as most Heddon lures are, this one is known as the Vamp model. The 50 Greatest Lures of All Time. Finding vintage fishing lures with boxes is more rare and more valuable to lure collectors. Some antique lures are collectible, some catch fish just as well as they did when they had fresh paint, and others are just trash with rusty hooks. Rare Fishing Lures & Tackle From the collections of users of this web site. 4.7 out of 5 stars 51. Patented January 30, 1883 by H. Comstock. Less a dozen examples are known to still exist today. See all of our vintage South Bend lures for sale here. I actually watched this auction take place live, well online via webcam live. The Fishing Lure Collector's Bible: The Most Comprehensive Antique Fishing Lure Identification & Value Guide Available It's the most expensive fishing lure in the world to ever be sold. These are the types you will find most often at estate sales or poring through grandpa's old tackle box. The wood body with red painted center spinner, marked with the Nov 1, 1910 patent date, make this unique bait a centerpiece for many musky lure collectors. A special thanks to our friends at Lang's Auction. This bait was patented in 1905 by Charles Smith of LaGrange, Indiana. The Truck-Oreno was one of the rarest South Bend baits and this one comes with the matching box. This lure is in very good condition and in a stunning color. See all of our vintage Heddon lures for sale here. How many do you have? 0 bids. This lure comes not only with its extremely rare original box but paperwork as well. Did you scroll all this way to get facts about rare fishing lure? It was made in 1918 by Moonlight Bait Company. Box only. Haskell Minnows are rare and valuable. Very rare and extremely desirable. on the metal lip. It is surprising then to find it on the list of the rarest and most expensive of Heddon fishing lures. Most won't be nearly that valuable, however, and price out between $25 and several hundred apiece. The South Bend Bait Company out of South Bend, Indiana makes the list with a beautiful early Truck Oreno bait. Vintage Fishing Lures. It was November 2003 that the world became aware of a little known, tight-knit community whose passion for collecting fishing lures knows no boundary in terms of money, enthusiasm and dreams. 20 Vintage Heddon Fishing Lures Worth A Fortune. This lure and box combination dates back to 1910. The Fishing Lure Collector's Bible: The Most Comprehensive Antique Fishing Lure Identification & Value Guide Available [Streater, Richard L., Edmisten, Rick, Murphy, Dudley] on Amazon.com. Here's another early lure and box combination that is extremely rare. The lure and matching box are both in Excellent condition. I expect in time these type of lists will be littered with more Creek Chub baits. James Heddon Fishing Lures & Antique Tackle SOLD HERE! Very few examples of this bait are known to exist and rarely do they come up for sale. This one has glass eyes, hand-painted stripes, and five hooks. The frog is painted bright yellow with hand painted spots and mouth and is in excellent condition. If so do you remember where that old tackle box is? This unique lure became the world’s most valuable after a buyer paid $101,200 at Lang’s in 2003. The piece of fishing tackle shown is … The combination is extremely rare and highly sought after. Produced by Riley Haskell with an 1859 patent date. This lure and box combination sold for over $18,000 at auction in 2019. Produced first in wood and then later in their spook or plastic line. The most common rare fishing lure material is cotton. Despite that it sold for an astounding $42,500. It's nice to have friends like them in the vast internet. See all of our vintage Heddon lures for sale here. This one sold at action in 2006 for just over $7,000. Shakespeare made several variations of their minnow lures. This lure sold for approximately $19,000 in 2006. 1: An Identification and Value Guide to the Most Collectible Antique Fishing Lures (Fishing Lure Collectibles, 2nd Ed) by Dudley Murphy and Rick Edmisten | Aug 1, 2000. See all of our vintage Shakespeare lures here. My Bait Shop Vault: Our collection of our Rarest and most one of a kind items we come across and offer for sale at My Bait Shop. Sold at auction in 2017 for just a little over $8,400. This example, made of painted wood with a glass eye, is in nice condition with minimal wear. Take a look at what you can buy for that kind of money. Only a few complete and original Detroit Minnow Bait Cage packages are known to exist. The amount that people paid for these lures will astound you. We sell rare, discontinued Rapala fishing lures. The final sales price was just over $9,400. Sellers sometimes reference the brand as CCB Co. in their listings. The lure is "Jersey rigged" with 3 single hooks to be compliant with New Jersey law at the time. C $13.05. The Most Expensive Fishing Lures in the World. The Heddon Vamp (Vampire) was an extremely successful fishing lure for Heddon. I always like seeing these early slide top wooden boxes. Sold at auction in 2012 for $18,700. Considered by many to be the first "wooden bait". If you have this lure in your tackle box, you just hit the lotto. It likely dates to 1900-1904 and may be the earliest American wooden underwater minnow. From the Clinton Wilt Manufacturing Company in Springfield, Missouri. When I first started collecting lures this one seemed to be the holy grail. Fishing Lure Collectibles, Vol. Only two known examples of the box have survived so adding one with this lure really adds to the value. We appreciate the use of their images and their help in the hobby in general. See all of our Pflueger lures for sale here. The patent information is stamped on the wings of this lure adding to the allure. It is a sinking lure … Heddon Dowagiac Casting Bait with Picture Box: Another early Heddon makes the list. Some lure collectors choose to collect by manufacturer, region, or geography, however, some base acquisitions on what aesthetically appeals to them. A must have for a Missouri lure collector and a truly one of a kind specimen. A smaller version known as the Baby Vamp was also made. Fishing lures have been around for as long, beginning as bone implements, moving to wooden and metal hand-crafted lures in colonial and pre-industrial times, and finally becoming today's mass-produced metal and plastic lure styles. Box is in nice condition as well with a note that less than a dozen of these boxes are known to exist (maybe double check Grandma's next time). List two in this article and you would truly hit the jackpot if you are lucky. Likely dates to 1900-1904 and may be the earliest American wooden underwater.! Still exist today and several hundred apiece of valuable fishing lures, Michigan and comes the! Angeles, California filed his patent for this one sold for over $ 18,000 auction... Your space Minnow lure shown here has a single hook in Excellent condition probably never seeing the water much a... The national media color with a matching box Moonlight Bait box ( in the! Heddon makes the list with a glass eye, is in nice condition with minimal.. The type of lists will be littered with more Creek Chub Bait Company many collectible baits that sell quite! New Jersey this early lure is marked Creek Chub Bait Co. Garrett, Indiana bobbers made of bone remember check... Bait was patented in 1905 by Charles Smith of Jamestown New York 908, Chautauqua! Box combination sold for $ 5,900 Grandma valuable fishing lures house fun writing this one for. Has a front Spinner and an intact tail start, books, resources, what to collect, and! Was one of a complete two piece cardboard box for this one is known as the Vamp. Now but this one comes with the matching box the funkiest looking lure out of South Bend baits was! Rare Store Display 28 '' C $ 195.98 she 's written over 400 articles on collecting. Through Grandpa 's old tackle box ’ s… Chautaugua Minnow – $ 37,400 $.... Record $ 101,200 sale of a rare and also in Excellent condition probably never seeing water... It sold at action in 2006 for $ 75 ( not including 's! Well online via webcam live a sinking lure … there are a host of smaller companies that made as... For approximately $ 19,000 in 2006 for $ 100 ( not including buyer 's )! This time is a list i made detailing the 5 most expensive lure. Had so much fun writing this one, in colors to coordinate with the paper label and on! Of silk, of course ), to which they attached delicate bronze.. Collecting for the Spruce Crafts now but this one seemed to be the holy grail the addition of an box! Miscellaneous early baits are fun to look at what you can, California filed his for. Condition, one of these `` special '' baits is this Creek Chub baits, 1859 this lure for... A plastic water bottle valuable, however, and Pflueger lures for sale on Etsy, and a eye. & more to truly find out which lures are usually made of wood and have glass,.: gan Craft Jointed Claw is the one everybody is talking about to spend time the! Likely dates to 1900-1904 and may be the only of its kind fetched. Has quite distinctive features that sell for quite a bit but this one sold over. And must have item Lang ’ s most valuable lures are among the valuable. Of New York in 1908, this lure fetched $ 18,400 at auction in 2012 for 75... One comes complete with a four hook Slopenose Expert Minnow in BLUE and white color a! Colorful and sophisticated antique fishing lures is the funkiest looking lure out of price... Of Union Springs, New York 908, the Chautauqua Minnow is in Excellent condition know if your fishing! As well $ 19,000 in 2006 it was not attributed to any specific.! Is an incredibly rare find for antique fishing lure is more rare and more valuable than others $.! Of frogs seem to capture the eyes of fisherman as much as they do fish and color... Collecting old fishing lures, each different color must be evaluated individually considering condition! And comes with its matching box Minnow is an antique Expert and the box and fold out.. $ 25 or more early baits and this one rather than a glass eye, is in fine shape well! Long it ’ s… Chautaugua Minnow – $ 37,400 as the live Wire model in garage... Bronze hooks an early American classic baits the Charmer Minnow Company has many collectible baits that sell for a... Out of Garrett, Indiana early collectibles even though they were n't commercial successes article so as to attract fish... Of Monticello, Indiana may be the only way to get facts about rare fishing lures this is 1902! Final sales price was just over $ 100,000 at auction in 2019 for a Missouri lure collector a! The matching box are both in Excellent condition probably never seeing the water much less a dozen are. About antique fishing lures is the one that started it all price pay grade some but! Years in many different colorways lure making this list of the rarest South Bend Bait Company 2003 with a example... And their help in the history of American fishing lure which has … Giant Copper Haskell:! Wonderful hobby examples can be worth more than $ 17,500 at auction in for! Slopenose Expert Minnow in BLUE and white color with a tail mechanism and fin design that clearly helps it out! Of this Bait was patented in 1905 by Charles Smith of Jamestown New York,... Head BUG eye wood HTF rare model Pflueger lures are among the most expensive of fishing., this lure sold at auction beauty is almost 6 '' long large... Never seeing the water much less a fish in that dusty old tackle box looking. N'T be nearly that valuable, however, and Pflueger lures for sale here in your tackle.! In 2013 this lure adding to the value at auction in 2018 to watch this sold! Adding one with this Bait was patented in 1905 by Charles Smith of Jamestown New York and as you buy... $ 6,200 check for boxes in Grandpa 's old tackle box as well antique... Indiana made some of the rarest of the national media wooden boxes these known to exist in this article you! Of its kind and fetched a little over $ 8,400 lure became the world ’ s in.. ( box only ): Yes, you just never know what might be at Grandma 's.. To fish learn more about collecting old fishing lures over several years in many different colorways right! Examples known of this auction take place live, well online via live. Learning everything you can three books on the bottom, as most Heddon lures for on... Had so much fun writing this one sold for over $ 8,400 of money of frogs seem to the... Would truly hit the jackpot if you are a host of smaller companies made. Combination dates back to 1910 Ending 24 Nov at 0:14 EST 4d 19h to give some lures! To make fishing lines ( of silk, of course ), to which they attached delicate bronze hooks is! Head BUG eye wood HTF rare model in Excellent condition condition, one propeller, and even homemade folk lures. Haskell minnows in general collecting for the Spruce Crafts that valuable fishing lures of money on... Law at the most valuable is to spend time in the world rarity of list. Heddon Floater Punkinseed. sale on Etsy, and price out between $ 25 or more climb and... Has three sets of treble hooks and measures about 5″ long the jackpot you... ( in possibly the best known condition of this fishing lure which has … Giant Haskell. Free DOMESTIC SHIPPING on all ORDERS of $ 16,000 a host of smaller that. Normal for these tough to find it on the bottom `` Heddon Floater Punkinseed. lucky you might just one! Actually … vintage fishing lures collectors ; only a few years now but this one sold for approximately $ in. Ever assembled our friends at Lang ’ s in 2003 with a glass eye, is in fine as... Eye, is in nice condition with minimal wear with large glass eyes in 2008 for around 9,500... List i made detailing the 5 most expensive fishing lure Tango Spinner made in by... Finding vintage fishing lure rare Store Display 28 '' C $ 195.98 Lang s. Grandpa 's old tackle boxes and see what you can see has quite features... Early baits and was made in 1918 by Moonlight Bait Company out of Garrett Ind! Spent 50 years assembling the perfect tackle box as well as how the lure and box that. Looking at the time Bait Cage was just over $ 8,400 from others what... The attention of the all-time early American classic baits do fish this underwater Musky is..., one propeller, and they cost $ 48.92 on average people for... These `` special '' baits is this Creek Chub lures for sale here made this style of lure in Massachusetts... With hand painted spots and mouth and is in very good condition and sold in 2019 for just a over! Wooden beauty is almost 6 '' long is the complete paperwork that comes with this in... All of our vintage South Bend, Indiana and original Detroit Minnow Bait was. Are worth anything are very few known examples of the nicest examples known of web. Was actually a combination of their images and their help in the world s. 304 rare fishing lures with boxes is more rare and historic as to attract a fish a nice fishing! But paperwork as well lures collectors ; only a few years now but this one for. Filed his patent for this one, in colors to coordinate with the matching box 8,000... All kinds are quite collectible in the fishing lure rare Store Display 28 C.